A Guide to Getting A Stronger Start When Working with Agencies
Creative briefs are essential to how marketing teams communicate with agencies, freelancers, and internal teams. But they are also where projects can quickly go off the rails.
In a survey from the consulting firm Better Briefs, 80% of marketers think that they are good at writing briefs. However, only 10% of agencies think so.
As a senior copywriter, I’ve seen the good, the bad, and the ugly of briefs. I may be a weirdo, but I always make a creative brief for myself, even if the client doesn’t give me one. Why?
For me, a creative brief is a tactical document. Many people online compare it to a roadmap. In my experience, it’s more like a battle plan. It tells you what you know, what you don’t know, and what you need to find out in order to create a successful piece of content.
Also read: The actual limitations of AI in marketing
Why good briefs are important
A strong creative brief is a key part of a successful marketing strategy. It can help a given piece of collateral convert faster. It defines the goal, the audience, and how success is measured for a given project or campaign.
When I get stuck on a project, I often go back to the brief to make sure I didn’t miss something or that the direction I’m headed in aligns with the original intent. A good brief can serve as the foundation for a range of materials, including multiple collateral pieces, outlines, and guidance on repurposing the finished content for other channels.
In a nutshell, a brief helps launch a project on the best possible terms and gives collaborators a common frame of reference to return to when things start to go awry.
What goes into a good creative brief
Generally speaking, most briefs are one or two-page documents. They are concise and direct. Since most briefs are digital these days, try to keep them under 300 words.
The components of a brief are based on each project’s needs. Adobe has a tiered system of briefs that can be useful to think about:
- Tier 1: These are non-standard, non-iterative, highly conceptual work, the most prone to ambiguity, so a creative brief is a requirement.
- Tier 2: These briefs build on previous work across deliverables, the already defined/completed work, so they don’t need the Tier 1 level of detail.
- Tier 3: Edits, revisions, templated work. These are the shortest briefs of all, but still need a project description to keep things on track.
In this framework, a Tier 1 brief might launch a website refresh; Tier 2 might brief individual sections or pages; Tier 3 might tweak or add a new webpage. Tier 1 will need the most detail, as it will be used to build out other briefs and guiding documents, such as outlines or project style guides.
But what actually goes in those briefs?
- Project name and tracking information: This field should include the working title of the piece and any tracking information. At Blue Star, we use unique project numbers to keep things clear.
- Type of project: A social media post needs radically different information from a blog post or an ebook.
- The goal of the project: The objective should be a quantifiable goal, such as gaining 50 new qualified leads by the next quarter or boosting engagement rates by 2% within X weeks/months.
- Target audience: In B2B, this is often directed at specific roles such as CIOs. In account-based marketing, this is often an audience of one or two pre-vetted companies, with specific roles or even specific people within those companies.
- Key messaging: What is the core idea that this content must communicate to the target audience?
- Timeline: When does the final version of the project need to be completed? What about the first review? The more detail given up front about expectations, the less likely to add tension down the road.
Stakeholders: Who is the point person and approval giver? Who else should be CC’d? - Call to action: Every piece of marketing collateral should drive the reader to take the next step. For a blog post, the CTA might prompt a reader to download a report, complete a survey, or sign up for a free trial.
- Distribution plan: Where will this content live? On your website, blog, or social media? How will you get the word out about it? Email? Paid social ads?
When creative briefs go wrong
I’ve seen a lot of briefs in my day. I see clients fall into the same pitfalls over and over again:
Not enough information
This is by far the most common mistake. For blog posts, consider who the target audience is, what their pain points are, and what your company’s unique angle is on the specific topic.
This is foundational information, not just for SEO but for AI search as well, and it can help a blog post rank well in both. The more information you give a creative team at the outset, the more likely it is that they will match your vision of the final product and achieve better results.
Too much information
This doesn’t happen nearly as much, but I do see it sometimes. A client might try to nail down a project as much as possible, even going so far as using AI to write a rough draft. While this is well-intentioned, being overly rigid at the brief stage can stifle creativity and hinder collaboration.
Not aligning internally, first
Often, a CMO or other higher-ups will delegate briefs to a team member. Nothing wrong with that. However, this approach goes wrong when the CMO doesn’t sign off on the brief before sending it to the agency. If the company has different visions of what the final version should look like, this can lead to infighting and resentment; more importantly, to hours of wasted time and retainer dollars.
Ways of working with a creative brief
In decades past, a brief might have been a physical piece of paper. Most of the time now, though, a brief is a digital document. At Blue Star, we use Trello, a Kanban board-based project management tool. We create the brief as a “card” on each client board, and then move it through the different phases of development–kickoff/initiation, writing, editing, design, and publishing. Any supporting documents, drafts, imagery, and final versions all go on the board. Clients and our team message about the project right on the card.
Who writes the briefs? It depends on the client. Often, our internal project management team will write a brief based on the client’s notes. Other times, the clients will create a card in the custom creative brief template that we have made and refined for them in Trello.
A few strategies we have noticed that work well include:
- Talk it through, then write it down: Get clear on the project’s scope first via a meeting, then codify it into a brief.
- Have a kickoff meeting for big projects: It can be very helpful for all collaborators to meet and review the brief, especially for launching larger initiatives. This gives everyone working on the project a chance to clear up misunderstandings and generally get on the same page.
- Make sure all stakeholders have visibility: Trello lets us copy team members on a board, and they get notified when files are updated or moved to the next phase of the project.
Creative brief hacks
It is a fine balance between clear, concise briefs and vague, unhelpful ones. Here are a few additions that can help move your creative brief from bad to good to great:
- Pain points: If you can clearly define the customer problem you want to speak to with a particular piece of collateral, you will already be miles ahead of many competitors.
- SEO/GEO considerations: If you have a set SEO strategy for web content, be sure to include it early so a writer can incorporate target keywords naturally into the copy. If you have any earned media connections, such as editors at trade magazines, be sure to include that as well, as PR media is becoming more important for AI search.
- Brand or style guidelines: If your company has a corporate brand voice or house design style, be sure to include it. This will help prevent misaligned content.
Templates/examples: Along those lines, if you have any internal templates or examples of similar content you like, this can help guide the creative. - Personas and ICPs: Marketing teams often have detailed personas of their ideal customers. Attaching this material can help your agency target the right folks and craft messages that speak to them.
- Company resources: Many organizations have troves of information, often on specific topics. The problem is, internal silos often make it hard for everyone to see it. Take a moment during initiation to see if your team has any prior collateral, research, or interview transcripts that might help compile the current project. It happens more than you might expect.
- Company subject matter experts or partners: Beyond internal content, are there any SMEs that can lend a unique perspective to the subject? Any partners or clients willing to add a quote or testimonial?
- Use AI thoughtfully: It can be tempting to have Claude or ChatGPT write a brief. Sometimes that’s the correct approach. But for more abstract Tier 1 content, be sure to spend a little extra “human time” developing the overarching strategy. (More on using AI for briefs below.)
Also read: The actual limitations of AI in marketing
To template or not to template
Blue Star doesn’t actually have a set creative brief template. That’s because each client has unique requirements. We help them craft better briefs and templates over time. But if you want to sort out a template for your organization when working with an agency, you would do well to start from the following B2B example:
- Title/Description: Launch of “State of Cybersecurity 2026” whitepaper for enterprise security teams.
- Goals: Generate 500 qualified MQLs via LinkedIn and email campaigns over 60 days; secure 50 demo requests from target accounts.
- Audience: CISOs, IT Security Directors, and VPs of Infrastructure at companies with 500+ employees; focused on organizations currently evaluating cloud migration or zero-trust architecture.
- Messaging/tone: Authoritative, research-driven, and pragmatic; emphasize risk mitigation, compliance, and operational efficiency without fear-mongering.
- Assets/deliverables: 20-page PDF whitepaper, landing page with gated form, three-part email nurture sequence, and a summary infographic for social sharing.
- Timeline: Internal kickoff June 1 → Draft review June 20 → Design finalization July 5 → Campaign launch July 15.
- Distribution: LinkedIn Sponsored Content, email blast to existing lead database, and syndication on industry-specific tech portals.
- Supporting documents: See the attached ideal client personas and survey data from last quarter.
How to use AI to brief better
If you are using AI to write a creative brief, why not go one step further and have it write the final content? Certainly, plenty of people are taking that route, but it’s a mistake. Why? In a word: quality.
Most people are using AI to boost content volume. But volume does not equal conversions (or sales). AI-generated content underperforms human-written content by a factor of 5, according to NP Digital.
In my opinion, the way to use AI is to make better content, not to shrink marketing overhead. And this includes writing better briefs.
Avoid generic prompts, such as “Write a creative brief for a blog post about pencils.” While most AI models can do just fine with this prompt, like a creative brief, prompts perform better with more information. Follow prompt best practices and give your AI tool a persona (i.e., senior-level marketing strategist), the task (a creative brief), context (any background on the project), and the format (a Word document).
Or just use AI to help you write a prompt to make a more comprehensive prompt and/or skill.
Below is a skill I made with Claude’s skill creator to help you write a better brief. Feel free to download. (For those who don’t use Claude, scroll down to the bottom of the post for the plain text version that you can paste and save in the AI platform of your choice.)
A good brief gives your content a boost
With the proliferation of AI content, standing out is more important than ever. AI is fast, but it rarely helps you convert. A good creative brief can give your partner agency an edge in creating high-quality content that drives traffic, impressions, and most importantly, sales.
Have a project your team needs help with? Get in touch with Blue Star Design to learn more about our fractional marketing services.
FAQs
I give excellent briefs. Why is the output from my agency not great?
Most of the time, creative briefs don’t have as much information as you think they do. Take some time to really put yourself in your target customers’ shoes. What problem is your product or service solving for them? What key messaging can you provide to your agency to help them convey that to the audience?
Who writes the briefs?
Brief ownership varies by setting. Within agency walls, it’s a partnership between the creative director and the project/account managers. For internal teams, the task typically lands with the stakeholders possessing the clearest grasp of the project’s core objectives and overarching goals.
Shouldn’t writing the brief be the agency’s job?
Yes… and no. The more information you can provide to a partner agency on your vision, expectations, and goals, the better the final product will be.
How much detail should I include in a brief?
Err on the side of too much information, especially for campaign briefs. Creatives can always pick and choose. Just avoid being overly prescriptive, as this can stifle creativity and discourage the happy accidents that often occur during writing or design that ultimately make a project better.
Bonus: Blue Star Design creative brief builder AI skill
(Copy and paste the text below into your AI tool and save as a skill to run whenever you need to make a brief for your agency.)
Walks a Blue Star Design client (or account person) through a structured intake interview to produce a complete, agency-ready creative brief for a new project or campaign.
How to run the interview
Ask the questions one at a time, conversationally — do not dump the whole list at once. Wait for the user’s answer before moving to the next question. Keep your own commentary brief between questions; this should feel like a quick, friendly intake call, not a form.
Ask in this order:
- Project title — “What’s the title of this project or campaign?”
- Project type — “What type of project is this?” (blog post, social media post, LinkedIn ad, whitepaper, ebook, etc. — if the user’s answer is vague, ask for the specific format/channel)
- Audience — “Who’s the audience for this?” Push for B2B specifics: industry, job titles/seniority (e.g., “IT directors at mid-market manufacturing companies”), not just broad demographics. If the user provides a generic answer (“business owners”), gently ask a follow-up question to narrow it down.
- Goal — “What’s the goal of this project?” Push for a quantifiable goal where possible (e.g., “50 new MQLs by the end of Q3,” “20% lift in organic traffic in 90 days”). If the user gives a soft goal (“raise awareness”), ask if there’s a number or timeframe attached, but accept a qualitative goal if they genuinely don’t have one — don’t block progress over this.
- Supporting documents — “Do you have any supporting documents — research, examples, competitor research, brand guidelines, personas?” If yes, ask them to describe or upload/list what they have (Don’t assume file uploads exist; check the actual attached files rather than take the user’s word that something is attached).
- Timeline — Ask for key dates: kickoff/deadline, first review, revision round(s), final review, and (if visual work is involved) graphic/design review. If the user only gives a final due date, ask if they want help backing into milestone dates, but don’t force it.
- Stakeholders — “Who are the key stakeholders and decision-makers on this project?” Get names/roles if possible, and who has final sign-off.
- Anything else — “Anything else Blue Star Design should know before we get started?” Open-ended catch-all — accept “nope” as a valid answer.
Edge cases
- If the user skips a question or says “not sure yet” / “TBD,” record that as-is rather than inventing an answer. Don’t stall the interview waiting for certainty.
- If the user front-loads several answers in one message (e.g., pastes title + type + audience together), acknowledge what you’ve got and skip ahead to the next unanswered question rather than re-asking.
- If the user uploads a file mid-interview, read it (per file-reading conventions) and pull relevant details (e.g., a brand guide can inform the audience/tone questions) rather than treating it as a black box.
Compiling the brief
Once all eight areas are covered, compile them into a clean, structured brief and present it in the chat as formatted markdown (not as a file yet). Use this structure:
# Creative Brief: [Project Title]
**Prepared for Blue Star Design**
## Project Overview
– Project Type:
– Goal:
## Audience
[industry / job titles / seniority]
## Timeline & Milestones
– Kickoff:
– First Review:
– Revisions:
– Final Review:
– Graphic Review (if applicable):
– Final Deadline:
## Stakeholders
[names/roles, sign-off authority]
## Supporting Materials
[list of docs/research/personas/brand guidelines provided]
## Additional Notes
[anything else]
Fill in “Not yet determined” for any field the user left blank, rather than omitting the heading — the brief should show the full shape even when incomplete.
After presenting the brief, ask if it looks right or needs edits. Once confirmed, offer (don’t assume) to also produce it as a Word document as well: “Want this as a Word doc too so that you can share it with the team?” If yes, use the docx skill to generate a polished .docx version and deliver it via the normal file-creation flow (save to outputs, present the file).
Notes
- This is an intake tool, not a grading tool — don’t critique or second-guess the user’s answers (e.g., don’t tell them their goal isn’t ambitious enough). Just help them articulate it clearly.
- Keep the tone efficient and professional, matching an agency intake call — not overly casual, not stiff.
- Don’t make anything up.